Carriage & Horses Menu (Updated 2026)

Carriage & Horses in Pine Mountain, GA, offers a refined dining experience set in a charming old Victorian farmhouse, blending rustic elegance with warm hospitality. The menu features standout dishes like tender Filet Mignon and Ribeye, each served with mashed potatoes, seasonal vegetables, and a rich demi-glace sauce that exemplifies the chef-owner Dagher’s dedication to fresh, quality ingredients. Seafood lovers will appreciate the indulgent Two Lobster Tails or the delicate Fish of the Day, paired perfectly with herb rice and hollandaise sauce. Starter options such as Shrimp Cocktail and Crab Cakes set a sophisticated tone, while desserts like Philadelphia Cheesecake and Tiramisu provide a sweet conclusion. This reservation-only gem is praised for its personalized service, with the owner often personally preparing dishes, creating a memorable and intimate atmosphere. Carriage & Horses is a rare find that combines exquisite flavors, attentive service, and a welcoming ambiance that invites both large gatherings and quiet celebrations alike.

Steak and seafood entrees dominate the menu, with premium items like Filet & Lobster Tail and Two Lobster Tails priced around $60, indicating a focus on high-value surf and turf options. More budget-conscious choices are available in appetizers, all uniformly priced at $12, offering a consistent entry point for starters. Main courses including Filet Mignon, Ribeye, and Fish of the Day are moderately priced at $35, providing mid-range options with classic steakhouse sides. Desserts are uniformly priced at $8, suggesting a straightforward, affordable finish. The menu composition supports a dinner-focused dining experience given the emphasis on hearty entrees and upscale ingredients.